Femina Potens: sexual expression as art & sexual exploitation = two different things (Part 2 of 3)

Betty.JPGPart 2:One of my biggest problems with western civilization is the consistent demonizing of sex across history.

Let me rephrase that: one of my biggest problems with western civilization is the demonizing of WOMEN who like sex across history.

If you read this column last week, you know that I wrote an erotic story; and, that because of my fear of being penalized in my immediate society for the expression of my healthy sexual fantasy in the written form I published it under the pseudonym "*RetroBangs73."

Upon reflection: it was like kind of the whole “Madonna/Whore” (and, no I don’t mean the pop singer) paradigm in my head. Because I work with children I’m not allowed to have sexual thoughts and fantasies – let alone express those thoughts and fantasies in a public forum for the world to see. That makes me a – gasp – pornographer and unfit to work with children.

Where did I get this idea, I wonder? When the truth of the matter couldn’t be farther from it: the healthy expression of my sexual thoughts and fantasies in an appropriate forum makes me quite a normal, healthy, balanced person.

I thought about this further and wondered why it is that no one questions suitability of, say – my brother – to work with children when he talks about publications like Playboy or makes a joke rife with sexual innuendo and double entendre; but, when I write a story about a girl losing her virginity what I’m losing are my part-time babysitting gigs left and right.

Seriously, said one mother who would prefer to remain anonymous in context of this column, “Kate I googled you and found Violet Blue’s article in the Chronicle and don’t think you're going to be suitable to work with our family.”

Said I, “Well [name redacted] did you happen to read the coverage associated with that article?”

“No,” said [name redacted,] “I did not. I figured that based on the fact that the sex columnist for the Chronicle was writing about you that it probably meant that you’re not fit to work with children.”

Said I, as I walked out the door, “You know, [name redacted,] you ignorant witch, if you’d actually read the coverage associated with that article you’d discover that I’m the victim in the situation not the victimizer.”

Thankfully, most people who I work for or with have understood that fact; and, other than by the harsh words a few narrow minded moms and a handful of innerweb pinheads I have not felt ill effects of either publishing my fiction, posting about what happened to me or allowing Violet Blue to share my situation with a greater audience. I will say, however, that [name redacted]’s reaction to this was exactly the type of thing which I had hoped to avoid by publishing under a pseudonym in the first place.

Which leads me back to my initial statement: one of my biggest problems with western civilization is the demonizing of WOMEN who like sex across history.

Why? I query why women are penalized for being either sexual or vocal about their sexuality, when had been a man been in this situation I reckon that nary an eyebrow would be raised or askance glance would cast their way when the erroneous association of an erotic work of fiction with child pr0n (a FALSE association, no less, created by less than scrupulous people hoping to profit off of me) was publicized in context of the larger issue of “spam killing the Internet.”

I’m sure that were I a guy that no moms would be questioning my suitability to work with their kids, I would not be receiving ten emails a day calling me a ‘whore’ and there would not have been an entry on **Encyclopedia Dramatica calling me “painfully homely and overweight.”

(Yeah, er... I’d love to actually see the pinhead who published that statement, I’m sure he/she is a work of art themselves.)

I think about these things and I wonder what the f- is so bad about healthy sexual expression via erotica or legal pornography causes such reaction as this?

Before we launch into a historical discussion of the puritanical values which have been perpetrated upon western civilization: let me point out that sexuality – or, heterosexuality, rather – in men is celebrated and considered of high value in our society.

Oh wait, the archetypical Hollyweird image of “feminine beauty” is valued in women… by men.

So it’s not that as a society we’re completely opposed to sex and sexual expression: it’s just that we want to limit it, it seems. To being something we women cannot participate in or have to adjust our own images to fit.

Why is it that people (such as [name redacted]) have such a difficult time delineating between healthy sexual expression and sexual exploitation?

And, why is it when women – particularly young women – dare to express themselves in even the most begin of sexual contexts is it that (seemingly) they are overwhelmingly exploited by assholes?

In regard to the theft of my story and reaction of ze innerweb pinheads, Violet Blue said via email, “I have many of my own stories to share with you, argh...”

I can only imagine she does: if this is the situation which occurs when a single story or Flickr photo is published, I can only imagine what happens when you publish a weekly column or book about sex, sexuality or *gasp*god forbid*gasp* a woman enjoying pr0n.

(FYI – Violet’s a smart, tough cookie and this is why I admire her. I have had trouble taking the criticism/shitty comments I have received for my one erotic story; and, I can only imagine what the pinheads say to/about her… I’d probably cry. Openly. In public.)

The screwed thing is that sex and erotica is all around us: in art through out the ages, in pop culture and in advertising used to sell commercial products to even the most frigid of individuals.

So why do we spend so much time demonizing it? Why - in the eyes of some - am I any different than I was the day before I published that story? Is it because I publicly expressed my sexuality? Is it because I was victimized and people assume that has f-d me up past the point of being healthy? (It hasn’t… I’m bruised, but fine.) Is it because people – in general – cannot think outside the box when it comes to the topic of sexual expression versus sexual exploitation?

If that's the case, then why is it that I have no trouble in the world understanding that difference?

These are all questions which I do not know how to begin to answer: When it comes right down to it, I am proud of who I am and what I do – the support of people who care about me and inspire me have helped me to get to that place; and, for those pinheads, of the innerwebs variety or in real life, such as [name redacted] – I am learning day-by-day how not to be bothered by your ignorance and hate – I’m discovering that you are the ones with the problem, not me.

I’m just an average, healthy creative, geeky, pr0n/erotica lovin’ writer girl a-whirl in the world.

*Name created partly in homage to Bettie Page, partly because I have retro-bangs and partly because I was born in 1973. Quit asking me why I chose that name now, please. Thxbai!

**At the time this column was posted the ED entry had been removed… I’m sure it had nothing to do with some smart geek girl who knew how to edit a Wiki deleting or editing the content of the entry twelve times in the span of 24 hours. If you happen to pop over to ED and see the entry republished after this column goes to press, please email me so that the edit/removal war can commence.

[Photo via Betty Page Archives]

Femina Potens: sexual expression as art & sexual exploitation = two different things (Part 2 of 3) - Comments

  • I hear what you're saying, Jaimie. The articles are focused on me, because it is a situation which happened to me. I can understand how you might perceive me as being "hysterical" - however, I'm only expressing the subjective feelings and thoughts which have occurred since this all began.

    Conversely, what happened to me - having copyrighted material ganked and published out of context - is something which has happened to a lot of other writers, photographers, etc. online. It is a situation which I chose to speak out about to better help educate people about the topic. And, since I have publicly done so certain groups of individuals have taken it as an opportunity to "cruelly lampoon" me online in ways which have had real life impact for me.

    If my reaction has been harsh or hysterical it is because I don't find the humor in someone calling me a "child rapist" (since redacted by Encylopedia Dramatica) or a "child pornographer" (not redacted on their website.) If I have seemed to go off on tangents in response to what seem to be reasonable comments to this article - which I wrote to help people understand this issue better - it's because while these comments may seem reasonable, I've been deluged in my personal email on my personal blog with ones which are not. Comments and responses which vary from "you're a whore" to ones which have explicitly detailed how they think I've victimized children.

    Not to mention that ED keeps trolling my blog for content and republishing it in a way which bumps their Google rating for my entry - which leads people to being able to find the "cruel lampoon" of me online - where they can read my name associated with atrocious ideas.

    Perhaps you can forgive my hysteria... ?

    The facts as they stand are: I wrote an erotic PG-13 story, it was stolen and exploited for a purpose it was not intended. In trying to help others in similar situations understand how to help themselves; and, in trying to help those not in similar situations understand how this kind of - seemingly benign - gank can negatively impact a person's life I have opened myself up to some extent to the criticism and bullshit being thrown back at me.

    Where I have a problem is that some people cannot distinguish between the following: what it is said I did and what I *actually* did.

    And, that now online people are exploiting upon my distress at this fact to further "cruelly lampoon" me or mock me in a way which REAL people continue not to understand is FALSE.

    I could care less if people want to disagree with me (I'm always open to constructive conversation) or make fun of me... Trolls and 4Chan kids and ED pinheads can comment all they want about me being untalented or fat or a whore or whatever...

    Where I draw the line is when someone posts something about me online (which is untrue) that has an impact on my actual - REAL - life. Not just upon my perception in the blogosphere.

    Which as we all know is "pretendy fun time games."

    Does that make sense?

    This article is subjective - it is wrapped around me - because, in fact it is what has happened to ME.

    (Just as the other articles I've written for DM have been about other women and their stories.)

    Jamie: I don't think you're trying to bully me... I appreciate your feedback. I didn't think that the chair/couch/desk/whatever were being particularly bullying, either... they have actually been the most benign of the ED commenters in the various places they've been trolling for my reaction.

    Jamie: If you care to, I encourage you to read all the surrounding coverage of this issue - both on my blog, Violet Blue's article on Open Source Sex and on various other blogs which posted about what was going on. Read the ED entry on me. Read the actual story I wrote (linked in part one of this series) and then determine if I'm off base in feeling... I dunno... like I'm getting a raw deal.

    Final comment from me on this article.

    Look for part three of this series (which will have steps to take should someone swipe your copyrighted material) on Friday, 11/2.

    Cheers,

    Kate

  • Jaime Molloy

    Could I suggest maybe (sorry, I'm not getting at you, I use my real name and email and you can even facebook find me) not posting for a while, calming down and then coming back to this subject at a later date?

    I can understand why you're so upset about it all but the articles featured on this blog and your subsequent responses don't seem to be portraying the person you probaby are (I don't know anything about you or have read the story in question)instead they seem to be a little hysterical and very much focused on you to the point that it seems to be just a forum for you to rant about your life under the guise of addressing a broader issue that doesn't really get addressed as it's swamped under your own victimisation.

    Again, I apologise, I'm really not trying to bully you or get at you but I can see that others obviously are and from a completely neautral standpoint it seems to be having the effect they desire.

  • Couchshelf: How is responding with what I viewed my issue to be insulting? I agreed that she had an interesting point to make. I hadn't thought about it. Further, I don't necessarily agree as I happen know a lot of guys who are elementary school teachers, nannies and child-care workers. None of whom have been discriminated against based on their gender or looked at askance when they became involved in the industry. I didn't even point that out; because, I thought it was unnecessary and not really what the crux of my thesis was, anyhow.

    Further if you'd like a specific example: I have one friend who is a pre-school teacher who has a tattoo of a naked woman on his forearm which has NEVER been an issue in his employment. The people who he works for/with know it's there. However, the tattoo is covered when he works with kids (long sleeves are the friend of many in SF) and no problem.

    Yet: again, I write a story about a girl losing her virginity and suddenly I'm not suitable to work with kids

    So, couchshelf - tell me who this jury is? Because if you're examining my actual life, I'd like to know how you came to a conclusion other than what I stated. If you have some insight as to what's going on in my ACTUAL life that I don't... please, please elucidate me as to what it is that's been happening. Because: in REALITY, where I've been looking for a part-time babysitting gig to replace the one which ended when a family I worked with moved out of the city... IN THAT REALITY: you know, like my actual life? There have been two mothers who directly cited using google to check on me, reading a small portion of the coverage surrounding the theft of my story and then stating "you're not suitable to work with kids."

    In my real life? Since I posted about what happened to my story and Violet's article ran I've received a LOT of attention from anonymous pinheads such as yourself who have sat on high and judged me without even really considering what happened and how it's impacted my life. Or, how calling me names (like "cunt guzzling whore" - that's my new favorite this week) via email, PM or blog comment is behavior far worse than anything I've done online. Or, how alluding to me being a child pornographer or a child rapist on some bullshit website is WRONG. Not just because I am NOT either of those things, not just because your easily flung insults have real life impact on people - but, because you all are too CHICKEN to come out from behind your 'Net anonymity and let it be know who is REALLY saying these things.

    I stand behind every single thing I post online and have done my best to deal with the group of you online bullies; as, I believe that you have to be willing to take the good/bad of what you post online... but, really. While your spammy/trollish crap is mostly annoying and easy to brush off as being as such - I'm beginning to understand what people like Kathy Sierra and others have been talking about when they say that they feel personally attacked by the constant harassment.

    Again: I didn't do anything wrong in my personal situation that has been deserving of the response I've received. My series of articles on DollyMix is an examination of what happened, how it made me feel and what I think people should do to prevent/deal with things like these happening to them. This specific post is about how I don't understand how the crafting of an erotic story (that, again, would merit a PG-13 rating were it a movie) has suddenly changed me into this whorish demon in some people's eyes. How I don't understand WHY women who enjoy sex or express their healthy sexuality via art are demonized; yet, men who do the same are on the whole not treated as such.

    In the context of things, you chair/ottoman/couch anonymous commenters on this blog (which is not my own, it is one I contribute to - this is not an opinion column, it is normally an interview column you may want correct the ED entry for accuracy. HAH, accuracy on ED - I crack myself up!) have been pretty intelligent and benign compared to some of the other crap being thrown at me. Thank goodness for Askimet spam blockers. Probably the only reason I've bothered responding.

  • couchshelf

    Talk about missing the point. This is the pattern: You say something totally ridiculous like \"I’m sure that were I a guy that no moms would be questioning my suitability to work with their kids,\" and Jaime politely points out that you are completely wrong. Instead of doing your readers the courtesy of responding when they initiate contact, you blow off whatever specific points they make in an irritating and insulting manner. Your inability to take even the slightest bit of criticism, as well as your ridiculous claims of suffering and persecution go a long way toward explaining why you\'ve been awarded an entry on Encyclopedia Dramatica. Btw, the jury examined your claims of \"losing my part-time babysitting gigs left and right,\" and returned a verdict of extreme skepticism.

  • Kate

    The other thing I think is really interesting about this whole situation is: I've been quite open and honest... yet the people who are intent on taking low blows (aka individuals at ED like "deskcabinet" and "ottomancloset") are ones who hide behind anonymity so that they cannot be held accountable for their cruel words.

    Interesting. Yet I'm the one who has something wrong with her? Ha.

    Like I said on my own blog: I'd love to see you guys in person... I bet you wouldn't even dare to say the things you've said about me online to my face. Cowards. The whole lot of ya.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Came straight to this page? Visit DollyMix for loads more stories!