Is it "let's have a go at abortion" week?

pregnantwoman.jpgIt's been a right old week for women who'd prefer to have control over their own bodies, hasn't it...

First, we have a Scottish Cardinal comparing abortion to 'two Dunblane massacres a day', which aside from being the most offensive thing I think I've ever heard coming from a 'man of the cloth', is just plain idiocy. Even a Sun reader could work out the flaw in the logic there, as indeed one of them did with the very fair point that on those grounds, 'every time a bloke has a w*nk he is "murdering" millions of little children'.

And as if that wasn't enough, once again the powers that be want to put more obstacles in the way of women in the unenviable position of seeking to end a pregnancy. A new bill, proposed by Conservative MP Ann Winterton, was rejected in Parliament yesterday, but that didn't stop 107 MPs agreeing with it: The bill would have imposed an obligatory 'cooling off period' of seven days to ensure a woman had made the right decision, as well as compulsory counselling sessions - the one part of the bill I would agree with, if only so that women don't feel they're making a fuss for asking as is the case at present. But a 'cooling off period'? It's for their 'own good', apparently, since *shock horror* abortions have been 'linked to depression'...

Let's go mad and just assume for a minute that this 'depression link' doesn't necessarily mean these women are depressed at having 'made a terrible mistake', as the assumption always seems to be. What about the possibility that an unplanned pregnancy and the additional anguish of having to terminate it may in itself be a fairly major source of stress. What about having to spend every day vomiting and -- in many cases -- racked with guilt while knowing that nothing good can come of it and that however much you might want a child you can't provide for it?

What about the already upsetting circus of appointments, scans, cost (or otherwise the already lengthy waiting time of the NHS) and the increasingly draconian element in the medical profession where 'religion' is often used as an excuse to prolong the ordeal of unintentionally pregnant women? Just a few of the many reasons why seeking to put obstacles in the way of these women is -- if anything -- entirely unnecessary.

The procedure itself, while traumatic, really is the lesser evil in this whole scenario, and making it harder to get to that final point of some relief is entirely unethical. If you want to throw pro-life arguments at me, go ahead; you've got your view and I've got mine. But don't try and tell me it's 'for my own good'.

Is it "let's have a go at abortion" week? - Comments

  • Yvonne

    hey Andy. Have you ever given birth? Do you have any idea how painful it is even when you DO want the baby? Or are you from the 'women should be punished for having sex' school of thought?



    Frankly, I don't think you're qualified to say.

  • Abi

    Andy> I don't see how we're disagreeing here; unplanned pregnancy is a stressful thing to go through. But you can't blame abortion itself for that. Quite a lot of women get depressed after having babies too, as is widely documented.



    Either way, when you're in a situation of having to terminate a pregnancy you can't cope with you're not deterred by statistics like this. Believe it or not, most women who are forced to resort to an abortion are already not very happy about it. Being pro-choice does NOT mean you go into such a procedure lightly or without a lot of sadness.

  • Andy Bunting

    Re. the statistics mentioned in the original article, no its not the stress of just having an unwanted pregnancy in the first place as the following extracts from a report show:

    The Bill has been recommended by leading psychiatrists and gynaecologists who quote the latest major research project – published in The Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry (January 2006). This shows that even women with no past mental health problems are at greater risk of psychological ill-effects after abortion. In the survey women who had had abortions had twice the level of mental health problems and three times the risk of major depressive illness as those who had given birth or had never been pregnant. The study caused the American Psychological Association last year to withdraw an official statement denying a link between abortion and psychological harm.

  • Andy Bunting

    I too agree that the Sun quote is rediculous. I am against abortion full stop, but surely after we have seen the pics of the 12-week old baby apparently "walking" in its mothers womb we can be sure that the cut off point as it currently stands is far too high as a fetus looks & behaves like a baby at a far lower time period than the current 24 weeks.



    I believe that human life starts at conception and for this reason myself, my wife and millions of others are against abortion, not because we are anti- woman, but because here you have two conflicting rights, ie those of the mother and those of the child. It's generally accepted that we cannot demand rights which deny others their fundamental rights, and the most fundamental of all is the right to life itself, without which, we fortunate ones who are able to debate these things might not be here at all, as has been the case for more than 6 million individuals in the UK since 1967. When you consider that in the case of late abortions unborn babies are often ripped apart in the abortion process, the Scottish cardinal's likening of abortion to Dunblane is not rediculous at all - Watch 'The Silent Scream' if you are not too afraid of having your opinions changed.

  • maz

    Well, what exactly IS the cut off point? It's getting lower and lower. Life is viable at 21 weeks, as the baby born in Miami earlier this year proves. [http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/20...]

    Every woman should definitely have the right to choose but not after 20 weeks. (And while I'm at it, what does 'the law' know about it?!) (That's just a rhetorical question btw..)

blog comments powered by Disqus

Came straight to this page? Visit DollyMix for loads more stories!